Today I'm joined by director John B. Benitz and Andrew Carroll to talk about the new documentary Behind the Lines. It's currently available on Amazon, Apple+, and Fandango. Annette Bening narrates, and the cast list is pretty stacked: Laura Dern, Gary Cole, Michael C. Hall, and Common to name a few..
The whole thing starts with a house fire in 1989 that wiped out Andrew Carroll's family memorabilia. When everything you have is gone in a night, you start looking at what gets left behind in other people's attics and basements. Carroll launched his war letters project in a "Dear Abby" column on November 11, 1998, and over roughly three decades he's tracked down more than 250,000 war letters and emails across every U.S. conflict. He's hit all 50 states and 40 countries, including active war zones in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Ukraine in August 2022, hunting for what he calls the world's great undiscovered literature.
What makes a movie like this work, or fall flat, is whether it turns real people into textbook footnotes. Here, actors read the letters alongside military historians and veterans, aiming for what war actually feels like on the ground rather than sanitized history.
Some of the letters that surface in the film don't fit neat categories at all. There's the one that kicked it off: Carroll's cousin writing to his wife on April 21, 1945, after walking through Buchenwald, giving a raw, graphic look at what he saw. There's a Black Union soldier writing to his former enslaver, who still held his daughter, flat-out warning him he was coming to get her. And then there's a World War I German housewife writing to her husband's commanding officer asking for him to get a quick leave home so she could satisfy her natural desires. Heavy stuff, dead-serious stakes, and occasionally a side of blunt human honesty you wouldn't expect in a history book.
Let's get into how this movie came together and what it took to get it made. Here's my conversation with John B. Benitz and Andrew Carroll about Behind the Lines.

Comments